جمع الأدلة على السرد المضاد: العمل غير المعلن لأرشفة العدالة واسترداد الأجور المادية المستحقة Collecting evidence of counter-narrative: the unspoken labor of archiving justice & recovering the material wages owed

شارك:
المجلة: Archival Science، المجلد: 26، العدد: 2
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10502-026-09540-1
تاريخ النشر: 2026-04-20
المؤلف: Sydney Mariel Triola
الموضوع الرئيسي: إدارة الأرشيفات الرقمية والتقليدية

نظرة عامة

في هذا القسم، يستكشف المؤلف دور الأرشيفيين المحليين والمهنيين المعلوماتيين كحراس أساسيين للسرد المضاد الذي يتحدى الظلم النظامي الذي تواجهه المجموعات المهمشة تاريخياً في الولايات المتحدة. ينتقد المؤلف تأطير هذه الجهود كمجرد “مشاريع شغف” أو نشاطات سياسية، arguing that such characterizations undermine the significance of the labor involved. By applying theoretical frameworks of immaterial and emotional labor, the author posits that these professionals should be recognized as experts and witnesses to injustice, particularly in light of the gendered and racialized disbelief prevalent in both the criminal justice system and broader societal narratives.

تؤكد الخاتمة على الحاجة إلى العمل الجماعي بين حراس السرد المضاد لمعالجة الفجوات في التعويض والاعتراف بعملهم. يبرز المؤلف الإبستيمولوجيا الاستعمارية التي تجرّد أولئك الذين يقاومون الهياكل القوية السائدة، suggesting that waiting for institutional change is insufficient. Instead, the author advocates for coalitions that can document trends of disbelief and demand accountability from judicial and legislative bodies. Through personal reflections on their own experiences and family histories, the author underscores the importance of reclaiming narratives and identities, framing counternarratives as essential acts of resistance against oppressive norms.

مقدمة

تتناول مقدمة هذه الورقة النقاش المستمر داخل دراسات الأرشيف حول الاعتراف بالسرديات المكونة من السجلات المحفوظة والمفهوم الإشكالي للحياد في هذا المجال. لقد أكد النشطاء والأرشيفيون المحليون على أهمية إنشاء سرديات مضادة لتحدي أنظمة القمع والسلطة. يتم تسليط الضوء على عمل إيدا ب. ويلز كمثال أساسي، حيث وثقت وانتقدت بدقة السرديات السائدة المحيطة بالإعدام، showcasing the labor involved in collecting and preserving evidence against such narratives.

يدعو المؤلف إلى تغيير في كيفية تصور أولئك المشاركين في عمل السرد المضاد لجهودهم، proposing that this work be recognized as labor. This recognition would not only validate the emotional and immaterial contributions of information workers but also empower them to organize as professionals within the field. By framing their activities as labor, archivists can confront the historical biases that have rendered their work suspect while simultaneously challenging the perception of neutrality associated with dominant institutions. This approach aims to foster a future where contributions to counter-narratives are acknowledged and compensated appropriately, thereby enhancing the credibility and authority of those who engage in this critical work.

نقاش

في قسم النقاش من الورقة، يستعرض المؤلف الأدبيات حول العمل غير المادي والعاطفي، خاصة في سياق إنتاج السرديات المضادة ضمن دراسات الأرشيف. يبدأ المؤلف بتأسيس فهم أساسي للعمل غير المادي، referencing Fortunati’s (2007) definitions and the contributions of scholars such as Marx, Tarde, and Sombart. تسلط المناقشة الضوء على تعقيدات العمل العاطفي كما عرّفه وارتون (2009)، مصنفة إياه إلى مواضيع تتعلق بالعمل التفاعلي وإدارة المشاعر الفردية. يؤكد المؤلف على الحاجة إلى الاعتراف بالعمل العاطفي وغير المادي الذي غالباً ما يكون غير مرئي والذي يؤديه الأرشيفيون وموظفو المعلومات، خاصة عند التعامل مع السجلات المؤلمة.

يستكشف المؤلف أيضاً مفهوم السرديات المضادة، drawing on Dunbar’s (2006) work to illustrate how narratives shape social power and the necessity of counterstorytelling to challenge dominant cultural narratives. ي complement this discussion, emphasizing the role of archival records in perpetuating systemic injustices. تشير الورقة أيضاً إلى استكشاف كولير وساذرلاند (2022) للشهادة والشهادة، arguing that these practices are vital for countering anti-Black narratives. في النهاية، يطرح المؤلف أن العمل المتضمن في إنتاج السرديات المضادة يؤهل كنوع من العمل غير المادي الذي يستحق الاعتراف والتعويض، خاصة في ضوء الأثر العاطفي الذي يتركه على أولئك المشاركين في مثل هذا العمل.

Journal: Archival Science, Volume: 26, Issue: 2
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10502-026-09540-1
Publication Date: 2026-04-20
Author(s): Sydney Mariel Triola
Primary Topic: Digital and Traditional Archives Management

Overview

In this section, the author explores the role of community-based archivists and information professionals as vital stewards of counternarratives that challenge systemic injustices faced by historically marginalized groups in the United States. The author critiques the framing of these efforts as mere “passion projects” or activism, arguing that such characterizations undermine the significance of the labor involved. By applying theoretical frameworks of immaterial and emotional labor, the author posits that these professionals should be recognized as experts and witnesses to injustice, particularly in light of the gendered and racialized disbelief prevalent in both the criminal justice system and broader societal narratives.

The conclusion emphasizes the need for collective action among counternarrative record-keepers to address the inequities in compensation and recognition for their labor. The author highlights the colonial epistemology that dehumanizes those who resist dominant power structures, suggesting that waiting for institutional change is insufficient. Instead, the author advocates for coalitions that can document trends of disbelief and demand accountability from judicial and legislative bodies. Through personal reflections on their own experiences and family histories, the author underscores the importance of reclaiming narratives and identities, framing counternarratives as essential acts of resistance against oppressive norms.

Introduction

The introduction of this paper addresses the ongoing debate within archival studies regarding the recognition of narratives formed from preserved records and the problematic notion of neutrality in this field. Activists and community-based archivists have emphasized the significance of creating counter-narratives to challenge systems of oppression and power. The work of Ida B. Wells is highlighted as a foundational example, where she meticulously documented and critiqued the dominant narratives surrounding lynching, showcasing the labor involved in collecting and preserving evidence against such narratives.

The author advocates for a shift in how those engaged in counter-narrative work conceptualize their efforts, proposing that this work be recognized as labor. This recognition would not only validate the emotional and immaterial contributions of information workers but also empower them to organize as professionals within the field. By framing their activities as labor, archivists can confront the historical biases that have rendered their work suspect while simultaneously challenging the perception of neutrality associated with dominant institutions. This approach aims to foster a future where contributions to counter-narratives are acknowledged and compensated appropriately, thereby enhancing the credibility and authority of those who engage in this critical work.

Discussion

In the discussion section of the paper, the author reviews the literature on immaterial and emotional labor, particularly in the context of producing counternarratives within archival studies. The author begins by establishing a foundational understanding of immaterial labor, referencing Fortunati’s (2007) definitions and the contributions of scholars such as Marx, Tarde, and Sombart. The discussion highlights the complexities of emotional labor as defined by Wharton (2009), categorizing it into themes related to interactive work and individual emotional management. The author emphasizes the need to recognize the often-invisible emotional and immaterial labor performed by archivists and information workers, particularly when engaging with traumatic records.

The author further explores the concept of counternarratives, drawing on Dunbar’s (2006) work to illustrate how narratives shape social power and the necessity of counterstorytelling to challenge dominant cultural narratives. Sutherland’s (2019) focus on state violence and the carceral archive complements this discussion, emphasizing the role of archival records in perpetuating systemic injustices. The paper also references Collier and Sutherland’s (2022) exploration of testimony and witnessing, arguing that these practices are vital for countering anti-Black narratives. Ultimately, the author posits that the labor involved in producing counternarratives qualifies as a form of immaterial labor deserving recognition and compensation, particularly in light of the emotional toll it takes on those engaged in such work.